Labour does not deserve our unwavering loyalty

Plabour2The cause of left unity in the face of an all-out assault on the working class by this Conservative government has never been more necessary nor more urgent, says Salman Shaheen.

But if Left Unity passes its first hurdle, bringing together the myriad squabbling clans who can sometimes seem to spend as much time attacking each other as they do their common enemy, then a much bigger hurdle awaits: Labour.

Even if we can put aside our own sectarian differences, there are those socialists in Labour who will see our movement itself as sectarian.

Before long we will run into the age-old argument that essentially boils down – paraphrasing The Thick of It – to our position in relation to the tent and which direction we’re pissing in.

There are those on the Labour left who’ll tell us that socialists should remain in Labour because the party is historically linked to the labour movement and is thus the site of working class universalism. They will say that New Labour is a passing storm that the left must weather by holding firm on deck, not jumping ship.

This is a very old idea, which no doubt many projects to establish a left of Labour party have faced over the years, and it’s one that has never failed to leave me feeling cold.

No political party reserves the right to go unchallenged. And no left-wing organisation deserves the right to be reified, to become a concrete fact in and of itself, to demand the unwavering loyalty of the workers regardless of its political positions. If that party is not the right vehicle for change, we should not be in it.

I simply cannot accept that because the Labour party was once the locus for progressive working class political activity that it should always be and will always be, irrespective of its current leadership and its present policies. That is the political equivalent of Creationism. It relies on nothing more than blind faith. Not least the faith that New Labour – a neoliberal, neoconservative, repressive war machine that, by gutting the Labour movement and accepting the basic tenets of Thatcherism has done far more damage to the country and the world than the Iron Lady ever could –  is simply a transient storm.

It’s been here for the best part of two decades and will remain for the forseeable future. No doubt Ed Miliband is an improvement on Blair. His denunciation of the Iraq War goes some way to atoning for the sins his Parliamentary party committed, and I have been impressed by his call to reinstate the 10p tax rate funded by a mansion tax. Such moves suggest the very first rumblings of Labour looking to its roots.

But despite the principled stance of some decent Labour MPs – and there are a number who deserve the left’s vote – Labour’s workfare betrayal proves that the fight against austerity cannot be left to Miliband. Nor should his party expect unwavering loyalty from the left simply because it is slightly better than the Tories, or from the working class simply because it has been ever thus.

It is precisely this kind of faith-based thinking which will continue the New Labour project long after Blair and Brown have faded to a dim, uncomfortable and embarrassing memory. New Labour is not a transient thorn. Its intelligent, educated and very bourgeois architects made a calculated, and very correct, decision that they can afford a sharp swing to the middle ground because whatever they do, their core support of left-wing voters will back them come what may. As long as they believe they can get away with that, New Labour will remain entrenched and the British working class will find nothing more than a few empty platitudes.

Parties cannot just be viewed in terms of their history. A week’s a long time in politics and a decade’s even longer. We have to look at their policies here and now and make informed decisions about the change they are likely to bring. Otherwise we’re betraying our own principles, all in the name of some ideological commitment to a homogeneous, united, organised, class-conscious Labour party of the last century that thanks to Thatcher, Major, Blair and Brown, no longer exists.

Of course the left in Labour should be supported, and I wish them well in their quest to reclaim their party. But the best way to do that is to show the Labour leadership that it cannot depend on the unwavering loyalty of the working classes no matter how many times it betrays them, how many neoconservative wars it backs, or neoliberal cuts it supinely acquiesces to.

The time for a new party of the left is now.


4 responses to “Labour does not deserve our unwavering loyalty”

  1. Dominic says:

    What you say makes sense and without a question of doubt the Labour party is no longer relevant from the Socialist perspective. However, the overriding problem which Left Unity must face, and solve, is how to re-engage a disenfranchised People. We have seen that, increasingly, over the years, the very people who are most in need of a truly Socialist government, and who form the overwhelming majority, are the ones who are least likely to vote. Whereas Tories, and the wealthy who would seek to protect their position, can be counted on to vote every time.

    How do we get those at the bottom of the ladder to re-engage and vote once more?

  2. Steve Pearce says:

    As a lifelong Labour voter it saddens me to say that New Labour will not get my vote at the next election. In the good old days of a true Labour Party I chatted with Minister of Defence, Dennis Healy, in my parents’ front room. Our house was the Committee room for the party during elections and at that time I could only believe in Labour. Now that New Labour have effectively acquiesced to Tory policy on Workfare and indeed made plans equally grotesque themselves they have gone beyond what I call fair. They have betrayed their root voters and abandoned the poor and needy in one step. They and the country will get what they deserve at the next election.

    • John Penney says:

      Although a lifelong Labour voter (simply because who else would I have voted for ?) I have never had illusions that the labour Party was other than a party of the capitalist status quo. However in past eras Labour was sometimes influenceable by the left and Labour Movement to at least not implement the most vicious of Tory policies during periodic capitalist crisis. That era is long gone . Today New Labour is an entirely pro capitalist , completely opportunistic electoral party wholeheartedly committed to defending the banksters and superrich at the expense of the working class majority’s living standards. This will not change, Labour is lost as a vehicle for resistance or radical change.

      Only a genuinely radical socialist party can have any chance of winning masses of people to a progressive social agenda – and away from the siren voices of bogus radicalism represented by the radical Far Right – who can also sound very “anti capitalist” and “anti establishment” to desperarate people facing wage cuts, bedroom tax threats, and benefit cuts and declining social services. As in Greece the major party politicians (including Labour !) in the UK are already well on the anti immigrant scapegoat bandwagon as a cover for their political impotence and collaboration with big Capital. And as in Greece, it is the radical Far Right that will reap the rewards of this disastrous scapegoating of ethnic minorities. We need a mass radical socialist movement to provide hope for a genuine, socialist, internationalist, route out of the crisis.

  3. janette says:

    we need a government that will listen one,s that are for the poor and needy none of the governments are for any of that they just lie spout what everyone wants to hear and never follow through with anything they say we need a new parliment with people who know what its like to struggle stop the banks getting big fat paycheck when they have put this country in dire its not the poor or lower working class that has done this to society its the government and corrupted corporations i,m sick to death of worrying about what this government has in stall for us next lets stop them they should be arrested for all the deaths they have caused and more will follow when are people gonna understand that the governments want us all to argue and fight each other putting friends and familys against each other this is a horrible corrupted government

Left Unity is active in movements and campaigns across the left, working to create an alternative to the main political parties.

About Left Unity   Read our manifesto

Left Unity is a member of the European Left Party.

Read the European Left Manifesto  


Events and protests from around the movement, and local Left Unity meetings.

8-12 Jul, Summer University

The Summer University of the Party of the European Left & Transform!europe in Aveiro, Portugal.

More info and register here

More events »


Sign up to the Left Unity email newsletter.


Get the latest Left Unity resources.

Broadsheet: Make The Rich Pay

Broadsheet: Ecosocialism Not Extinction

Transform Journal – Issue 9

More resources »